How to Reduce Your Building’s Insurance Costs: A Practical Guide for Leaseholders and RMC Directors
How to Reduce Your Building’s Insurance Costs
A practical guide for leaseholders and Resident Management Company (RMC) directors
When it comes to your block’s annual budget, buildings insurance is often the single biggest expense. Rising premiums, changing market conditions, and increased rebuild costs all contribute to higher service charges for residents.
The good news is that this is also one of the easiest areas to review and make real savings — without cutting corners on essential protection. With a proactive approach, leaseholders and RMC directors can ensure that their insurance costs are fair, transparent, and competitive.
Here’s a practical, step-by-step guide to help you take control of your building’s insurance costs.
1. Understand Who Arranges the Insurance
In most leasehold blocks, the freeholder or landlord is responsible for arranging the building’s insurance policy. The freeholder then recovers the cost through the service charge paid by leaseholders.
Typically, the lease gives the freeholder the authority to choose the insurer, level of cover, and renewal terms. This arrangement makes sense — after all, they legally own the property — but it doesn’t mean the cost should go unquestioned.
If you suspect the premium is higher than it should be, you have every right to ask for clarification. Request a detailed breakdown of the policy and evidence showing that the cost is reasonable and in line with market rates. Transparency is key to avoiding inflated premiums.
2. Know Your Legal Rights — The “Reasonableness” Rule
Many leaseholders don’t realise they are protected by law. Under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, landlords and managing agents must ensure that all service charge costs — including insurance — are “reasonably incurred.”
You have the right to ask for:
- A summary of the insurance policy
- Full details of the cover provided
- Copies of the insurance schedule, renewal documents, and supporting paperwork
This rule ensures that leaseholders only pay for fair and necessary expenses. If your freeholder or managing agent refuses to share the details, they may be in breach of their legal obligations. Having access to the policy documents gives you the power to make informed comparisons and spot potential overcharging.
3. Get the Documents and Shop Around
Once you have the insurance documents, the next step is comparison shopping. Contact at least three different insurance providers or brokers that specialise in residential blocks.
Make sure you compare like for like — the same:
- Type and level of risk cover
- Rebuild value of the property
- Policy excess amounts
- Claims history and renewal conditions
For example, two insurers might both offer £10 million in rebuild cover, but one may charge a significantly higher premium due to a higher excess or recent claims.
If your building has a good claims record, you’ll often find that another provider can offer identical protection at a better rate. Even if you’ve had claims in the past, presenting evidence of improved risk management (such as upgraded fire safety systems or CCTV) can help secure lower quotes.
4. Share Better Quotes with Your Freeholder or Managing Agent
If your research reveals a lower, comparable quote, send the details to your freeholder or managing agent. Include a clear comparison table showing the existing policy versus your alternative quotes.
They can then:
- Re-negotiate with their current insurer
- Switch to the provider you suggest
- Agree to review the market at the next renewal date
In some cases, they may choose not to act. However, simply demonstrating that you’ve taken the time to research alternatives can motivate them to review the pricing and ensure competitive rates.
💡 Tip: Keep all your communications polite and professional. Most managing agents appreciate an informed and evidence-based discussion rather than accusations of overcharging.
5. If Nothing Changes — Know Your Rights
If your landlord or managing agent ignores your concerns or fails to justify the cost, you don’t have to accept it. You can escalate the issue to the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber), formerly known as the Leasehold Valuation Tribunal.
This independent body can determine whether an insurance cost is reasonable and whether the landlord’s choice of insurer is appropriate.
Before taking this step:
- Write a formal letter requesting a response and justification for the insurance cost.
- Set a reasonable deadline — around two weeks is typical.
- Keep a record of all correspondence.
If there’s no satisfactory reply, you can apply to the Tribunal under Section 27 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985. While it’s often a last resort, the very act of mentioning the Tribunal is sometimes enough to prompt a fair review from the freeholder.
6. Bonus Tip: Prevent Future Premium Increases
Prevention is better than cure — and that applies to insurance too. The fewer claims your building makes, the lower your premiums will be in future.
Here are a few proactive ways to keep costs down over time:
- Improve building security: Install secure entry systems, CCTV, or better lighting.
- Reduce water damage risks: Regularly check roofs, gutters, and pipes.
- Maintain fire safety standards: Ensure alarms, sprinklers, and extinguishers are up to date.
- Document risk improvements: Keep records of upgrades or maintenance work to show insurers at renewal time.
Small actions like these demonstrate responsible management, which can make your building more attractive to insurers and help negotiate lower rates year after year.
7. Key Takeaways
- Buildings insurance is often the largest expense in a service charge.
- Leaseholders have a legal right to question and inspect the insurance documents.
- Always compare like-for-like quotes from multiple providers.
- Share your findings and encourage your landlord to seek competitive rates.
- If costs remain unreasonable, you can escalate to the Tribunal.
- Prevent future premium hikes by maintaining good safety and claims records.
In Short
Taking an active role in reviewing your building’s insurance doesn’t just save money — it promotes transparency and fairness for all residents.
With the right information and approach, you can ensure that your block’s insurance costs reflect real market value, not inflated premiums.
Being proactive today can save your block hundreds or even thousands of pounds every year, without ever compromising on protection.